Detecting Fallacies Online

For this assignment, I decided to analyze an article by Jennifer Casa-Todd called, “New Research: Social Media Has (Maybe Not) Destroyed a Generation.” In the article, Casa-Todd argues that many fears about social media harming young people may be exaggerated. She uses several research studies to support her point. While the article makes strong arguments, there are a few possible fallacies we can see using ideas from Crusius and Channell (2016).

One example is hasty generalization. The author shares studies that show social media does not strongly harm teens' well-being and may even have benefits. While these studies show positive or neutral effects, it’s possible that some teens are still negatively affected, so the conclusion may not apply to everyone. Therefore, the evidence cannot fully support such a broad statement about an entire generation.

Another fallacy is either/or (false dilemma). The article suggests that if we blame social media, we miss the chance to support kids. This makes it seem like we must choose one or the other. However, in reality, we can both talk about the potential risks and help young people use social media responsibly at the same time.

There is also a possible bandwagon reasoning. The article lists a lot of respected organizations and studies to support its argument. While this adds credibility, just because many groups agree does not automatically make the claim completely true. Readers still need to evaluate the evidence critically and carefully.

As Crusius and Channell (2016) explain, it is very important to look closely at claims and evidence to see if the reasoning is strong and logical. Careful analysis helps us understand the argument and avoid being misled by fallacies.

References:

Casa-Todd, J. (n.d.). New research: Social media has (maybe not) destroyed a generation. Retrieved February 28, 2026, from https://jcasatodd.com/new-research-social-media-has-maybe-not-destroyed-a-generation/

Crusius, T., & Channell, C. (2016). The aims of argument: A text and reader (8th ed.). McGraw-Hill Education.

Comments

About Me!

Hi everyone! My name is Avery Pleiman, and I am currently a freshman at Oregon State, majoring in BioHealth Sciences on the Pre-PA track. I am from Independence, Kentucky, and currently live on campus in Corvallis, Oregon. This is my first communications course, and I’m excited to learn more about different ways to communicate and improve my skills throughout the term. I use online communication a lot to stay in touch with friends and family, share updates on social media, and keep up with school-related resources. The platforms I use most are iMessages, Snapchat, Instagram, and TikTok because they are fast, easy, and fun. I like using them not just to connect with people, but also to stay organized and see what’s going on in my family and friends’ lives, especially since I live far from home. A little about me personally: I play on the OSU women’s soccer team, which takes up most of my time and keeps me busy, but I love it. Being part of a team has helped me learn responsibility,...

A Lifelong Friendship Through Knapp’s Relational Model

Interpersonal relationships are always changing, even the ones that have lasted the longest. One of the most important relationships in my life is with one of my best friends, and someone I’ve known since Kindergarten. Although our friendship started when we were young, it has continued to grow and change over time. Using Knapp’s Relational Model, I see our current relationship fitting best into the intensifying stage. Growing up, we spent a lot of time together. In grade school and high school, we had similar routines, classes, and activities, which made it easy to hang out regularly and stay close. As we got older and closer to college, we both chose to pursue sports that took us in different directions. She chose to run track at a school near home, and I chose to play soccer at a school across the country. Distance and demanding schedules meant we no longer saw each other in person as often. Communicating online became very important to keep our friendship and help us stay connected...

Early Start Times: A Questionable Debate

For my blog post, I wanted to choose an argument I could relate to and understand from a personal perspective. For my weekly blog, I chose the argument of school start times because I’ve heard a lot of back and forth from both sides. I also haven’t been on Reddit before, so this was a whole new experience for me, trying to find an argument about this. However, I chose this Reddit thread because the topic is relatable to almost everyone, and they also question why schools start so early if research suggests a later start time. As someone who used to and still struggles to wake up for school, I was interested to see what people thought. This discussion quickly turns into a debate, with commenters sharing strong opinions, personal stories, and frustrations. One concern I noticed is that a lot of comments would say opinions as facts without citing any research. Also, the original post mentions that it’s “proven” to be harmful, but very few responses include credible sources. Another i...

AVERYDAY BLOG

Search This Blog